Exotic Seafood Survey #4: Sea Scallops

Sea scallops have become omnipresent on local menus, even though they come from waters far away from New Orleans. Air shipping of seafood makes it possible for us to enjoy fresh scallops in our restaurants, and sometimes even from our grocery stores.

Unfortunately, we’re also still getting the not-so-fresh scallops, too. Like as not, those are the ones you’ll see in the supermarkets. More on that–and the little bay scallops, too–later.

Back to the good news. The best sea scallops are the big ones. They come from the Atlantic in the same parts of the Northeast that give us good lobsters. They range in size from about an inch across to the size of a petite filet mignon. Scallops, like most mollusks, veer from the general seafood rule that smaller is better. I find the biggest ones most interesting.

The scallops you’ve enjoyed in the best restaurants are gathered and shipped with better-than-average care. They’re known generically as”dry-pack” scallops, meaning they have not been immersed in a preservative chemical. “Day-boat” scallops (gathered in one day’s fishing and rished to market) or “diver” scallops (actually gathered by divers instead of dredges) are the best of the dry-pack scallops. These have the superb sweet flavor of fresh shellfish, with just a light searing at the outside. (They should bulge at the sides when cooked.) They’re also good raw as sashimi.

The part of the scallop that we eat is analogous to the eye of an oyster. It’s the adductor muscle, the one that keeps the shell closed. Only rarely do you see the entire surrounding tissue left intact. If you try that, you learn why we only eat the white part.

Before cooking at home, wash scallops exceedingly well. They sometimes contain fine sand. It’s disconcerting to enjoy the flavor of a scallop and then be put off by a gritty sensation in chewing. Even in good restaurants I find this now and then.

Once in a very great while, scallops have the orange roe sac attached. Depending on which chef you ask, this is either wonderful or something to be got rid of. I like it, perhaps as much for its rarity than its intrinsic goodness.

The little bay scallops are about the size of miniature marshmallows. Although they are prized in the Boston and Cape Cod area when they’re fresh in season, almost all bay scallops you’re likely to find have been either frozen or treated with a phosphate chemical that extends their shelf life. Acceptable for people who go to places like Red Lobster (which sells tons of them), but nobody who really knows seafood.

As for the bigger sea scallops, most what you see in stores were dredged up from the sandy sea bottom and processed by what amount to floating factories. The phosphate chemical enters the picture, extending the length of time they can be sold at retail but giving a chemical taste and a strange texture to the teeth. Not only that, but the chemical is so effective that sometimes you can’t get the treated scallops to brown, no matter how hot the pan is.

2 Readers Commented

Join discussion
  1. Martha McCord on April 16, 2014

    Sautéed, baked, fried, ??????

    • Tom Fitzmorris Author on May 3, 2014

      Seared is my favorite, but there are other methods. I have several recipes for scallops in the recipe section of NOMenu.com.

      Tastefully yours,
      Tom Fitzmorris