A caller to the radio show is so enthusiastic about everything that I find myself in a trance listening to him talk, and I want to drop everything after the show to try a place he gushed about. His success rate on making his excitement contagious is 100%.
A few months ago he started telling me about a BBQ pop-up at one of his favorite places, Capt Sid’s in Bucktown. He has long extolled the virtues of Capt Sid’s, but this new twist has him plenty titillated. Naturally, my interest is piqued.
After a Saturday meeting at Deanie’s recently, I saw the smokers across the street at Capt Sid’s and wandered over to try some barbecue. I wanted brisket, but they were sold out, so I settled for Cola pork Spareribs, choosing the collard greens and cowboy beans as sides.
I was disappointed but not surprised that the first few bites didn’t thrill me. Fortunately, I had already eaten, so I took this plate home to eat later.

The following day I put this in the oven and didn’t return for over an hour. There was no liquid in the dish. It would have to cook in its own fat. When I returned to it, I expected to see a dried-up mess.
The cowboy beans and collard greens did not fare so well, but the ribs were marvelous. The cola-rubbed perimeter was black and crusty, and inside the meat had shrunk to expose more bone. The excess fat that offended me on the day of purchase had melted into the meat, making it impossibly tender. This neglected reheating vastly improved the entire thing. I still loved the sides, especially the cowboy beans. They were everything I want in that BBQ side.
I have thought about these ribs somewhat often since that day, and I have tried to get back there for more. Finally, I had the occasion to be over on a Saturday, and I got there early before they sold out.
They had been open only a half hour when I walked in at 11:30 am, only to hear them announce, “That’s it for the ribs,” as the person ahead of me ordered the last of them. A half hour??? That was it???
I turned around to see what was left on the whiteboard. They had the brisket I had been looking for the last time, and they had a Cochon de lait as well as pulled pork. The brisket was Wagyu, which I didn’t need, but I got it anyway. For sides this time, I got the potato salad and coleslaw for one plate, and on the other I got more collard greens and corn pudding.
The brisket was an enormous portion, but at least 50% was fat. That explains the need to lift the carton with two hands. I’m going to put this in the oven like I did the ribs last time, and maybe I will love it like I did the ribs, but only after an hour in my oven.

The potato salad was from Capt Sid’s, and I could taste the crab boil in it. My tastes with potato salad seem to be changing, because I liked this smooth but not especially creamy potato salad. It had just a few small chunks of potato, but it was quite good.

I wasn’t sure why the corn pudding was called that because it was also dry, not sweet, and teeming with corn kernels. I don’t know that I’d get this again, but it was fine.

Both the collard greens and the coleslaw were quite spicy. I loved this chunky and crunchy coleslaw. It was creamy and vinegary at the same time. There were slices of red onion as well as purple cabbage. It was colorful and really quite delicious.

The collard greens are leafy and chunky, and filled with all kinds of leftover meats. This was quite spicy too, but I liked them very much.

The meat on this second plate was the Cochon de lait, and I regretted getting it immediately. Pork can be gross in texture if it is too fatty. This had that texture.

There are chicken wings on this menu that are smoked, then fried. I will go back to get some of these when I return for the pork ribs. I am determined to have those again.
Getting those will be a challenge. The BBQ pop-up at Capt Sid’s is so wildly popular, I wonder if any seafood is being sold on the days the BBQ is there. I hope so. Capt Sid is obviously as great a guy as my caller has told us. He gave a pop-up spot to a friend who did movie catering before that dried up. It has become such a phenomenon beyond their wildest imagining. A good story usually makes the food better. But this barbecue doesn't really need a good story. I'm still glad there is one.


