Delmonico Returns

September 14, 2026
Delmonico Returns

Now at The Fairmont

When Emeril Lagasse bought the old Delmonico’s from Miss Rose and Miss Angie Dietrich back in the 1990s it was thrilling. The lovely sisters who had inherited the nearly century-old

restaurant from their father had found a good steward. They knew that Emeril was a stable buyer, and he had promised great things for it, though it would be a completely different place.

Even Tom was happy about the plans, though it meant that another one of his cherished old classic New Orleans neighborhood restaurants would live on only in the memories of the many who loved it.

Shortly after the sale, Delmonico became something entirely different. It was a glamorous steakhouse with a hopping piano bar, and a place to see and be seen.

A mere few years later, Katrina roared into town, and the restaurant was no more. The building still sits unoccupied, rotting away, almost certainly to be razed at some point for land value. Too bad.

What is interesting is that Emeril has opened a few other Delmonio’s in other places, so the New Orleans version of the name carries on. Emeril’s name always precedes the use of the historic NYC steakhouse to distinguish the two.

But Emeril’s Delmonico has just recently resurfaced here in New Orleans at the new Fairmont Hotel, which arrived almost quietly late last month at Common and O’Keefe, a block from another fancy neighbor, the Roosevelt Waldorf Astoria. People seem to confuse the two. The Fairmont ran the Roosevelt from the end of the last century well into this one for many years, when The Waldorf Astoria took over. This new hotel is a return to the city for the hotel brand.

The hotel is stunning in that 2026-style of visual assault. It is gorgeous and…dark. I find this mood unsettling, but that is sadly definitely the current trend. And that statement comes from  a Fairmont fan.

Emeril provides the food for the hotel in The Cafe and Emeril’s Delmonico. It is a handsome place with friendly waiters wearing that old Galatoire’s attire. I loved that.

Tom is rolling over at how quickly I run to new places, but the restaurant was celebrating its eight-day open when I dropped in for dinner. (I’m embarrassed to write that.) But I got excited by the menu online, and I had business in town.

Unfortunately, a lot of what interested me on the menu was tweaked out, leaving behind a pretty straightforward steakhouse menu. I rarely eat steaks in a steakhouse, at least by myself, so this was a blow to my plans.

I still found two apps I wanted. They had crispy pork cheeks with collard greens, dirty rice, and chow chow. I also ordered Barbecue Shrimp. I view Emeril as the father of modern barbecue shrimp (though the credit belongs to Gerard Maras). Gerard added Worcestershire, and Emeril “kicked it up a notch” to a sublime sauce with an insanely rich consistency.

There were two entrees on the menu that were not steaks: a Gulf fish Amandine and a chicken dish. I’m always about Amandine but never Redfish. I passed when they told me it was the ubiquitous local fish this evening, leaving boring chicken, though I fully expected it not to be boring. This was Emeril’s Delmonico, after all. And I got sides of creamed spinach and a side of creamed corn grits.) And there were, of course, the newly required menu item of croquettes, but I passed.  I need to do a piece on just croquettes around town. Move over, crispy Brussels sprouts!

The Barbecue Shrimp came in a beautiful presentation of five large shrimp with a sort of biscuit alongside a pool of exquisitely beautiful, rich sauce. This was sublime. Truly sublime. The barbecue sauce in town, in my experience. Emeril is still the king of this dish.

But it was the biscuit!!! I use that term cautiously. It was more of a Pastryscuit. It was flaky in a fantastically unusual way, and really dense. The absolutely perfect foil for a sauce this rich. Incredible!  I loved this so much I want an apocalyptic stockpile of these. 

I was less enthusiastic about the pork cheeks. First, I was surprised that they were fried, though it did say crispy in the menu description. I have never seen them like this, though they were very tender. This could have been a great dish but wasn’t.  The dirty rice had little flavor, which was the most disappointing thing about it. The collard greens were fine. Chow chow is fun and I like seeing it on menu items. And the dish was almost cold, though not quite as cold as in I-had-to-send-it-back-for-heating, like I did for the creamed spinach. 

In the case of the spinach, that was the least of its problems. It was stringy and had absolutely nothing to recommend  it. I took it home and will use it as a base to craft real creamed spinach. It made me wish I had gotten the everywhere side of potato croquettes.

The creamed corn was unusual. It couldn’t tell if it was grits or creamed corn. There was plenty of creamed corn and a hint of poblano somewhere in this. Very unlike the spinach, it came to the table so hot I had to wait for it to cool.

The chicken was indeed boring. It was an airline chicken breast with a light sauce, plenty of roasted fingerling potato pieces, artichoke pieces, and oyster mushrooms. There wasn’t anything actually wrong with this, except that it was on the menu at Emeril’s Delmonico. I would have thought they might have been more creative in a place like this.

The missteps I mentioned were handled immediately and gracefully. Everyone here is pleasant and helpful. I loved the staff.

Especially when they offered to carry my boxes to the car. Believe it or not, there were no bags for little carry-out boxes. 

These are little problems befitting the first few days of opening, but I have often said no one should open a restaurant in these days of social media without firing on all cylinders. That goes double when there is a reputation to maintain. 

As for my first impressions, I think it will be a great and often-visited restaurant here. I think it will be very popular with business people with nice expense accounts. My bill was $161 with tip for one person drinking only water.

At least the name Delmonico is back in a working restaurant in New Orleans, and that’s something.

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment.