It was heartbreaking to hear that The Pizza Man of Covington had closed its doors. We have countless memories of nights hanging at Pizza Man with the kids from the time they were pre-school age. Until Katrina.
The Pizza Man was originally from the upper Midwest, Minnesota, I believe. He was a hippie from back in the day and still had a long gray ponytail under his toque. He was always smiling and enjoying the hordes of children who watched from behind large plate-glass windows, mesmerized, as he flipped his pizza dough and threw a dusting of flour at the glass.
Our kids were some of the countless who stood on the step to see better as the Pizza Man crafted their pie. Barb the waitress used her artistic abilities to draw on pizza boxes, which lined the walls of Pizza Man. The gigantic thousand-piece puzzles that Paul and his wife worked on in his daytime hours (they were only open for dinner) filled the remainder of the open space on the wall. The scene was charming Americana. A jukebox sat by the bathroom, and it was always in use, playing things like “Puff the Magic Dragon” to remind the parents to treasure moments just like those at Pizza Man, while they had the chance.
The menu was simple: pizza and a wonderful Italian salad. There was pepperoni, cheese, and sausage with everything. But Tom always preferred the Board Special, which was garlic and olive oil, fresh spinach, and capicola ham, fresh mushrooms, onion, and feta cheese.
When Paul finished his performance for the kids, the pizza went into the classic pizza slamming door oven on his old pizza pans with a mesh lining. The pizzas were good, but the crust was the weakness. The middle was often soggy, especially Tom’s Board special. I always wondered why Tom was so enthusiastic about the pizza at Pizza Man, until I realized it was his heartstrings that voted the loudest.
The ingredients Paul used on his pizzas were of unwavering top quality, making up for any deficiencies like that soggy crust. Paul retired over ten years ago, and one of his two sons took over the pizza making. I don’t know what happened to the fun waitress who drew on the boxes.
The last time we went to Pizza Man was during COVID, when the realization that the warnings in "Puff the Magic Dragon” had indeed come to pass was made more acute by the dark pall cast by COVID. Tom was ill, and I'm sorry that it was my last memory of this place that had meant so much to our family.
When ML told me what she had seen on Facebook, it broke my heart, though I was not surprised. The Pizza Man had made it 50 years, and they decided that was enough. The sign on the glass said Thank you for 50 years. We are all healthy, and looking forward to new adventures.
That was the perfect way to end it, and exactly what I would have expected from Paul. They are looking for someone to turn the key, and I hope someone does. It’s the perfect place for families in this perfect place for families.
The announcement about Pizza Man made me more curious about another pizza place across town. Tommy’s on Thomas has just moved into the space opened when Fat Boy’s moved out. Tommy’s on Thomas is also a 50-year-old pizza place, and an institution in Hammond. I was excited to hear of another place coming here to serve pizza, as I remain hopeful for a really good New York-style pizza in the area. Fat Boy’s was more amusing than good, and that finally caught up with them, I guess. Tommy’s moved into the spot at 21 and I-12 last month.
A look at their menu revealed that there was much more than pizza here, and I had high hopes…with reservations.. I saw things on the menu that made me hopeful. They were making potato chips. And frying their own tortillas for the spinach dip. I ordered spinach dip, housemade chips, cheese fries, fried eggplant, and a small pizza.
The pizza looked like a pre-made dough from the pictures online, but I held out hope. I have no idea if that is the case, but I have seen frozen pizzas with more appeal. And the taste was on par with that.

The red sauce with the fried eggplant was a little sweet and otherwise not very good. The fried eggplant was too dark for my taste, but the breading was nice and the eggplant tender.

Judging by the appearance of all of this, I was even more shocked to see them making potato chips in-house. It didn't comport at all with the rest of these offerings. The chips were fine. Crispy and crunchy, this was the best thing on the table.

I ate the potato chips with the spin dip, which was actually fine. It had a creamy texture and a nice flavor. The accompanying fried flour tortillas were too dark.

There wasn’t anything here that I need to have again, and nothing that I will remember even tonight. And that is so disappointing as I continue my quest for good New York-style pizza on the Northshore.
This 50-year-old pizza establishment is hardly a replacement for The Pizza Man, and that is too bad on so many levels.
And none of these musings answer the bigger question: what’s going on with Fat Boy’s?

