One of my favorite topics on The Food Show that has earned it the moniker “A geriatric whinefest” (I do so love that!...and I wear it as a badge of honor.) is the erosion of the culinary culture of New Orleans. It was what The Food Show is, and what Tom was, all about. He relished our strong culinary culture., and I do too. It’s only now that I am doing the show that I understand the noise that encroaches on our treasured traditions. The buzz about hip places that are short-lived. The irrelevance of stalwarts of our cuisine (at least in the media.)
When the Po-Boy Fest (a bastardization in itself. It’s a poor boy!) first started 18 years ago, the entrants in the competition were doing traditional seafood and meat sandwiches with the standard dressings and our cherished local condiment Blue Plate Mayo.
It was a few years later that the lines began to blur, and this year’s winners haven’t a single traditional poor boy on the list. The Best of Show went to Junior’s on Harrison for their cleverly named Pho-rench Dip sandwich which was pork, cilantro, herbs and lemongrass salad with a ginger aioli and fried noodles with a Vietnamese dipping sauce. The vegetarian/vegan winner was from Breads on Oak. It was an oyster mushroom poor boy. Why didn’t anyone enter a French fry poor boy? That’s the original. And can there even be a vegetarian poor boy, much less a vegan?
Another winner was a sushi poor boy from Seither’s in Harahan, a newly hot place from their exposure on Diner.Drive-ins, & Dives. The shrimp poor boy winner was from Mahoney’s. They won that category with their hot honey fried shrimp sandwich.
Just for yucks, I went to Junior’s and picked up the winning Pho-rench which was running as a special Thursday. And I got the Mahoney’s Hot Honey Shrimp sandwich. That was as far as my Fierce Traditionalist sensibilities would go.
I’m generally not a fan of Junior’s American food, so maybe I’d like this better. I picked it up and the minute I got it into the car I had to open the windows, so strong and unpleasant was the smell of the dipping sauce. I really hate to say that, because the Vietnamese diaspora brought enough Vietnamese people to this area to influence the culinary culture almost the way the Sicilians did at the start of the last century. But it is not the same.
It is often said that learning the Chinese language uses a completely different part of the brain as English, whereas the Romance languages all derive from Latin roots, making it less difficult to learn another European language. (Even though English is not technically a Roamce language, it does use Latin roots and shares many more similar traits to the Romance Languages than it does to its Germanic classification.) I feel that way about Asian flavors, and Middle Eastern flavors. The spices are so completely different from a flavor profile, that I just don’t think true fusion is possible.
Because of the work ethic of the Vietnamese people, they have become a powerful force in the economic engine of theis city, and they operate a number of restaurants around town that have been trendsetters. The fusion of these favors into seafood boils around town has attracted enough fans for there to be multiple locations of these places. Their hard work has paid off and I am happy they have found a large following.
I can’t be part of this following, but I do love their baked goods. Their time as a French territory brought French baking techniques to the natives and these traditions still survive. Chez Pierre in Metairie and O’Delice on Magazine St. are good examples of this. And Minh Bui of Cafe Minh does a great job of mitigating strong flavors into a blend with French food at his delicious Canal St. eatery.
But back to the poor boy from Junior’s. The meat was shaved into very thin slices, and there was a lot of fat on each piece. I am a big fan of cilantro, though its strong flavor makes it impossible to taste anything else. The sandwich was overwhelmingly flavored with the herb salad with ginger and lemongrass. And the dipping sauce was as strong as it smelled. Not for me, but I already knew that.
I went to Mahoney’s for the hot honey shrimp and discovered them cooking outside. The power was off as trucks from Entergy worked on poles outside the building. The staff worked efficiently under a small tent outside in the alley, cheerfully keeping up with orders. The menu was limited but the hot honey was one of the offerings. I got to watch them craft these sandwiches. Shrimp went from an ice chest into the fryer where they emerged hot and crispy, to be tossed in a bowl with the housemade hot honey. There was less heat and more sweet in this mix, but it was a nice sandwich. I don’t need to get it again, and I am mystified by why everything now needs a dousing in hot honey.
When I first went to The Po-Boy Fest in the beginning, it was hard to choose which version of the traditional poor boys I wanted to eat. Now it would be hard to find anything I wanted to eat, though I would definitely have gotten the hamburger poor boy from Parkway. Maybe next year they could have a Traditional class, where the competition focuses on the flavor of the batter of fried shrimp, and the execution of the frying, the flavor of the roast beef gravy and the style of the beef itself. The condiments and their flavors. There can be a lot of variation in the traditional sandwiches keeping the basics traditional. It takes skill to differentiate oneself from others when nuances are involved. It’s cheap and easy to go for the latest trend and the wackiest version. New Orleans is about classic food. One can only wonder what the folks from Martin’s Poor Boys would say about this year’s winning sandwiches.
I can hear the judges from this Po-Boy Fest now…”What’s Martin’s Poor Boys? And why are they calling po-boys poor boys?”


.jpeg&w=3840&q=75)